27 June 2007

Intelligent Design in Chesterfield County's Science Classes?

I've set up this blog in order to organize community response to a statement [pdf] that the Chesterfield County Virginia School Board appended to its Textbook Adoption Memorandum [pdf] on 22 May 2007. The local media coverage so far has been restricted to an article in the Chesterfield Observer, a column in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, and an unsigned editorial in the same newspaper. There have also been a number of letters to the editor in both publications on the topic. There has been some coverage of this on science and ID blogs as well.

The statement appears to be a result of pressure from individuals and groups, including the Family Foundation, who want intelligent design (ID) to be included in the school's science curriculum. Although the School Board statement doesn't sanction (or even mention) the teaching of ID in Chesterfield's science classes, it appears to promote a set of guidelines that might be viewed as a de facto endorsement of ID, as long as students are the ones who introduce the "debate" into the classroom.

Here are a few problems that some of us have with this statement:
  • The language is extremely vague and equivocal, and it may send different messages to different people. Some of us have asked the School Board to clarify its statement, but they have been unresponsive so far.
  • By urging teachers and students to explore "alternative views," it appears to promote one of the main ID talking points--"teach the controversy."
  • It appears to remove control of classroom content from teachers by encouraging students to engage in an "unimpeded" and "unrestricted" study of "an almost infinite number of [Internet] resources" as part of the learning process. This is not necessarily a bad thing, but it appears to encourage students to supplement (corrupt?) their classroom instruction in evolution with ID materials from the Internet.
  • Although the statement is broadly applied, evolution is singled out as a topic that, "along with all other topics that raise differences of thought and opinion, should receive the thorough and unrestricted study we have . . . articulated." The statement therefore appears to urge students and teachers to investigate a controversy about evolution that doesn't really exist.
  • The final paragraph appears to encourage students to discuss ID as a form of religious expression in their science classes (this is an unusual formulation--most ID advocates argue that it is science). This seems to strain the conventional understanding of how religion can be expressed in schools, and it likely conflicts with legal decisions (e.g., Kitzmiller v. Dover) that have ruled that ID cannot be taught in science classes. It may also lead to uncomfortable and embarrassing situations for students who introduce ID into science discussions, because their teachers would be obligated to tell them that ID is not a legitimate scientific alternative to evolution.
I encourage others to submit other ideas and comments on this statement.

Although the main audience for this blog is the metropolitan Richmond, Virginia area, I welcome any help we can get from others who have had to battle this problem elsewhere.

At this point, we need to do the following:
  • We need more people to write letters to the Richmond Times-Dispatch and the Chesterfield Observer to counter the numerous letters from ID proponents who are largely spewing the standard Discovery Institute talking points.
  • We need more people to attend School Board meetings, or to express their concerns to the CC School Board directly.
  • We need local clergy to get involved--especially those who might have signed the Clergy Letter Project.
  • We need to let get as many people in Chesterfield County involved in whatever ways we can.
  • We need to get candidates to explain their positions on this topic before the November elections.
Please contact me if you want to be involved, but don't feel comfortable posting to the blog.

17 comments:

Don said...

At the last two meetings, the School Board seemed to give a lot of support to the ID supporters but little to the teachers in the classrooms.

I would like them to issue another statement stating their support for the science teacher who gives a failing grade to the student turning in paper on the evolution of birds or such and only quotes creationism.

Shawn Smith said...

Excellent point, Don. I think we need to present the SB with a list of the very real potential consequences of their extremely vague statement.

Anonymous said...

Stop the IDists from tricking people into accepting an opinion about ID as though that opinion constitutes a definition of ID.

See http://intelligent-design-hypothesis.com

Don said...

Everyone should look closely at the upcoming 2007 Chesterfield County School Board elections. Some candidates will "insist" on pushing ID into our schools' science classes.

Anonymous said...

[color=#f5deb3]Музыканты [url=http://dejavu-group.ru/index.php]Дежа вю[/url] - это коллектив профессиональных вокалистов и музыкантов.
[url=http://dejavu-group.ru/about_us.php]Dejavu-group[/url]- законодатель в области организации и проведения торжеств, музыкальных мероприятий, корпоративок .
В репертуаре ВИА Deja Vu около 3 тыс. произведений.
Живая музыка. Ретро, хиты 70-80-90-х, джаз, диско, поп, современная музыка, европейские хиты, фоновая музыка, шансон.
Музыкальный ансамбль Dejavu-group обладает мощной качественной музыкальной аппаратурой, которая позволяет заполнить приятным и плотным уху звуком как маленькое помещение (фуршет), так и огромное помещение (корпоратив до 1 тыс. человек).

Игорь +7 916 623 4047 [/color]

Anonymous said...

[color=#f5deb3]Музыкальная группа [url=http://dejavu-group.ru/svadba.php]Deja Vu[/url] - это коллектив заслуженных вокалистов и музыкантов на праздник.
[url=http://dejavu-group.ru/svadba.php]Дежа вю[/url]- лидер в области музыкального сопровождения корпоративных вечеринок, свадеб, торжеств, шоу программ, музыкальных вечеров.
В копилке ВИА Dejavu-group около 3000 произведений.
Только живое исполнение. Ретро, хиты 70-80-90-х, джаз, диско, поп, современная музыка, европейские хиты, фоновая музыка, шансон.
Артисты на праздник Дежа вю располагает мощной качественной музыкальной аппаратурой, позволяющей наполнить плотным и приятным уху звуком как небольшое помещение (фуршет), так и большое помещение (корпоратив до 1 тыс. человек).

Игорь +7 916 623 4047, Андрей +7 910 483 8294 [/color]

Rizwan ali said...

i am regular visitor of your site and you are writing very nice so keep posting university admission

Anonymous said...

Для продвижния вашего сайта есть хорошая база каталогов ссылок.А так же: Добавь своё объявление и оно автоматически разошлётся на сотни досок. И у Вас будет свой сервис рассылки бесплатных объявлений. Вместе с сервисом рассылки бесплатных объявлений Вы получаете и генератор посещений - отличную приманку для посетителей. Данный сервис можно установить на любом беслатном хостинге. [url=http://www.ffrees.ru]Смотрим здесь[/url]

ged schools said...

The idea is very innovative.

Anonymous said...

Want more science articles? Go to http://factsintext.blogspot.com

Lapel Coins said...

you have provide a great information.

Anonymous said...

Битторрент трекер KINORELIZ.NET предоставляет возможность абсолютно бесплатно закачать бесплатно торрент фильмы, музыку, игры, книги, программы, документацию. Торрент трекер - отличный вариант ускорить просмотр фильмов или прослушивание музыки.

KINORELIZ.NET Торрент трекер: [url=http://kinoreliz.net]торрент скачать[/url]

Anonymous said...

Если вы задаетесь вопросом, как зарегистрировать предприятие, не владея необходимой правовой подготовкой, то правильнее обратиться в ООО "Регистратор". Ведь для самостоятельного оформления всех необходимых документов необходимо время и знания, так как любая ошибка может обойтись слишком дорого. Высококвалифицированные специалисты ООО "Регистратор" возьмутся качественно оформить компанию.

Юридические услуги: [url=http://www.registratorfirm.ru/howtoregfirm/]как оформить ооо[/url]

Anonymous said...

Несмотря на с первого взгляда простоту, регистрация в качестве ип требует соблюдение установленных норм и правил, поэтому лучше доверьтесь профессионалам, которые имеют практический опыт такого рода. Если вы полюбопытствуйте, как оформить ип, вам ответят очень просто.… Опытные юристы ООО "РЕГИСТРАТОР" возьмут всю процедуру оформления и регистрации вашей организации, на себя...

Как открыть и оформить ИП или ЧП: [url=http://www.registratorfirm.ru/openip/]оформление чп[/url]

Anonymous said...

Eхcellent post. Keep posting such kind of infoгmation on your site.
Im really impressed bʏ youг site.
Hi therе, You have done a fantɑstic job. I'll definitely digg it аnd perѕonally suggest to my fгiends.
I am sure they will be benefited fom this websitе.


Here is my website; weight loss diet youtube

Anonymous said...

Excellent blog yoս have here but I was curious if you
knew of any community forums that cߋver the same topіcs talkeԁ aƄout
in this artіcle? I'd rеally love to be a part of ߋnline community where I
can get feed-back from other knowledgeable pеople that share the same interest.
If you have any rеcommendations, pleɑse
let me know. Ƭhankѕ a lot!

Heгe is my website: Chevy trucks Forum

Anonymous said...

Saved as a favorite, I love your blog!

my website: best e-cigarette product